|
Reed Slatkin Media
Resource |
| Earthlink co-founder
Reed Slatkin, an unregistered investment manager and ordained Scientology
minister, admitted to defrauding clients of approximately 255 million dollars in
a Ponzi-type investment scheme. Many of his victims were fellow Scientologists;
others were wealthy investors with Hollywood connections. Scientology
has a long history of association with financial scams. How much of the money
Slatkin took in was funneled to Scientology organizations ? And how many of his
fellow Scientologists were in on the arrangement ?
news:
|
|
| |
| LA Times |
| Dan
Jacobs Sentenced to 4 Months
2005-10-27 |
 |
|
A former Southern California business consultant received a four-month prison
sentence for conspiring to obstruct a Securities and Exchange Commission
investigation of financial advisor Reed E. Slatkin’s $593-million investment
scam, federal prosecutors said Tuesday.
Daniel W. Jacobs helped stall the SEC for more than a year by pretending to
represent a Swiss brokerage holding hundreds of millions of dollars in funds
from Slatkin investors, according to his plea agreement with the government.
Jacobs, 63, who pleaded guilty and cooperated extensively with prosecutors,
is expected to serve his time near his Michigan home, said Assistant U.S. Atty.
Michael Wilner.
At Jacobs’ sentencing Monday in Los Angeles, U.S. District Judge Margaret
Morrow also ordered him to repay $450,000 to victims of Slatkin’s schemes.
Also, AP story here:
Daniel W. Jacobs, 63, of Burbank pleaded guilty three years ago after
agreeing to cooperate with federal prosecutors in their case against
Slatkin.
Authorities say Jacobs lied to the Securities and Exchange Commission and
provided false documents so victims’ investment statements in Slatkin’s Ponzi
scheme would seem legitimate. He also acknowledged fabricating account
statements and setting up false phone numbers to make it seem like a Swiss firm
held hundreds of millions of dollars in investor money. |
 |
| Los Angeles Times |
| Slatkin Associate, Girlfriend Face Tax-Evasion
Indictment
2004-11-17 |
 |
Federal prosecutors announced tax-evasion
charges Tuesday against former Grateful Dead road manager Ronald L. Rakow and
his girlfriend in connection with a scheme to conceal Rakow’s income, much of
which he earned working for convicted Ponzi scheme operator Reed Slatkin.
Assistant U.S. Atty. Michael R. Wilner said Rakow diverted $5.2 million
that he received from Slatkin and other sources to his girlfriend, Denise Del
Bianco, from 1998 through 2001.
At the time, the Internal Revenue
Service was trying to collect $2.2 million in unpaid taxes from Rakow, according
to an indictment returned last week. Del Bianco paid income tax on the funds,
but the alleged diversion kept the IRS from seizing Rakow’s cash and securities
outright, the indictment alleged.
Rakow "falsely made it appear to the
IRS that he had only minimal income and assets with which to pay the unpaid
tax," the indictment said.
Rakow was charged with tax evasion and
falsifying tax returns. Del Bianco was charged with aiding and abetting tax
evasion and also with wire fraud. |
 |
| Associated Press - San Francisco Chronicle |
| Settlement reached in investor-related Ponzi scheme
2004-09-15 |
 |
Former bankers for EarthLink co-founder Reed
Slatkin have agreed to pay $26.5 million to settle a lawsuit alleging that they
helped him appear to be an investment advisor while he operated a multi-million
dollar Ponzi scheme.
Attorneys involved in the 2-year-old lawsuit said
the last of the documents were being signed Monday but still must be approved by
U.S. District Judge Margaret Morrow in Los Angeles. The recovery would be the
largest yet for investors in what Slatkin has admitted was a fraud that began in
the mid-1980s and was revealed in 2001.
The settling defendants included
Union Bank of California and Bank of Orange County. Other defendants were
Imperial Management Inc., the former trust division of Imperial Bancorp, an
Inglewood bank acquired in 2000 by Comerica Inc., and Mary Catherine Leider, a
former vice president in Imperial’s trust division who handled accounts for some
Slatkin investors.
Full text available here. |
 |
| |
| Off Topic - Echoes of
Slatkin seen in new Ponzi scheme
2004-06-15 |
500
Investors see $200 million disappear |
| Check out FourStarFraud.com - a site
not unlike this one, dedicated to unraveling the aftermath of a high stakes con
game. The numbers (200+ million from 500+ investors) and location (Southern
California) certainly harken to Reed’s Ponzi scheme. The most significant
difference between Four Star Financial Services and Reed Slatkin, though, is
that the Four Star fraud was allegedly perpetuated by financial advisors - real
ones, unlike Reed and his cronies. Be sure to read the Wall Street Journal
article - the top news story on the site. |
 |
| SEC / Stockwatch |
| Jean Janu to plead guilty
January 12
2004-01-01 |
 |
Slatkin ex-bookkeeper Jean Janu has agreed to
plead guilty at an arraignment scheduled for January 12. From a December 10,
2003 SEC
release
:
In her plea agreement, Janu admitted that, at Slatkin’s direction, she
created and revised account statements and other documents that supported
Slatkin’s claim that he held over $500 million in securities in brokerage
accounts at the fictitious entity "NAA Financial" of Zurich, Switzerland. Janu
knew these documents were to be submitted to the SEC. Janu created these bogus
statements on her computer and printed the NAA account statements on blank,
European-sized stationary provided to her by Slatkin that contained NAA’s name
and purported Swiss address. Slatkin then instructed Janu to erase the account
statements from her computer.
Additional coverage can be found at stockwatch. |
 |
| LA Times |
| Victims of Slatkin May Get More Money Back (free registration
required)
2003-12-11 |
 |
The Los Angeles Times reports on what may be an early Christmas
present for Slatkin victims -- Trustee Todd Neilson has now doubled his estimate
for debtors, and now suggests that investors could get back as much as 40% of
their money. Of course, he explained to the court earlier this week, that all
depends on whether the net winners pay back the "profits" that came from the
pockets of less fortunate Slatkin Investment Club members:
In a memo presented at a hearing Monday before Bankruptcy Judge
Robin Riblet in Santa Barbara, Neilson said the 20-cent reckoning was made at a
stage of the case when "it was very difficult to estimate with any degree of
reasonable accuracy possible payout percentages."
The main reason for
the uncertainty was the fact that only some of Slatkin’s clients were paid back
more than they invested — a common occurrence in such so-called Ponzi schemes,
which use funds from later investors to pay phony profits or dividends to the
earliest participants.
Neilson sued 430 of these so-called "net
debtors," seeking the return of anything they received in excess of the amount
they put in.
So far, 144 of those suits have been settled — typically at
about 80 cents on the dollar — for a total of $31.8 million, most of it to be
collected in payments over the next two or three years. For example, tobacco
litigator John Coale and his wife, legal commentator Greta Van Susteren, agreed
to return about $700,000 of the $939,000 they netted.
Suits seeking an
additional $138 million are pending against other defendants, including actor
Peter Coyote, who made $943,000.
If those defendants "were to simply
find it within their hearts and wallets to pay the $138 million without any
further litigation," Neilson wrote, it would yield a return to the creditors of
84% of their losses.
But Neilson called that scenario "highly unlikely."
A "more realistic approach," according to his memo, would be to assume that 35%
of the $138 million can be collected by spending an additional $7 million on
litigation — a formula that would bring the recovery to about 40% of the losses.
Slatkinfraud.com wishes the best of luck to net
losers, and joins them in hoping that the net gainer gang, in Neilson’s words,
"finds it in their hearts and wallets" to help hundreds of investors begin to
put the whole Slatkin mess behind them. |
 |
| slatkinfraud.com |
| Some Scientologist Slatkin
victims still not happy with Neilson
2003-12-11 |
 |
Despite the good news on higher than expected
returns, some of Slatkin’s Scientologist victims have long been unhappy with the
performance of trustee Todd Neilson. A small band of aggrieved net losers --
all, apparently, Scientologists -- have launched another court challenge against
Neilson’s handling of the case, as reported last week by the LA Times [registration required
for link]:
In a letter Wednesday to the office of the U.S. trustee in Los
Angeles, the investors complained that 10 legal and accounting firms had
submitted $19 million in bills as of June. Meanwhile, unsecured creditors in
Slatkin’s bankruptcy have received only $12 million so far.
"We are
petitioning you to step in and take action to stop the runaway fees in this
case," the investors wrote. "Many of us are middle-income people, who lost
substantial sums to Slatkin." Scientologist attorney Steve
Hayes has filed a formal objection to the fees [warning: large PDF file] on
behalf of Scientologist net losers Kendell Dorsett, Michael McGahee and Ann and
Seymour Thomas. Another group of Scientologists, led by Jane Allen, has filed a
similar motion, and Scientologists David
Curtis and Thelma Rosenkranz have also filed pro per objections with the
court.
(Curiously, the self-proclaimed pro per Ms. Rosenkranz appears to
have misspelled, and then corrected, her own name at the top of the letter. An
errant T preceding the Z in her last name seems to have been struck out with a
pen on the original document.) |
 |
| LA Times |
| Ex-Slatkin Associate Is Sentenced in Scam (registration
required)
2003-12-02 |
 |
| A former associate of Santa Barbara
investment scam artist Reed Slatkin was sentenced to five months in federal
custody and five months of home detention for obstructing a federal probe and
lying to investigators. Richard D. McMullin, 39, worked as an assistant in
Slatkin’s office from the mid-1980s until 1999, handling phone calls from
investors, helping to create account statements and researching stocks. U.S.
District Judge Margaret Morrow ordered McMullin to pay a $4,000 fine. Assistant
U.S. Atty. Steve Olson said McMullin paid $1.55 million in restitution to the
bankruptcy trustee to help make up for his role in the scam, which fraudulently
raised $593 million from some 800 investors over 15 years. |
 |
| Los Angeles Times |
| Law Firm in Slatkin Case
Agrees to Pay $650,000
2003-09-17 |
A court
trustee says the asset manager’s attorney should have uncovered his pyramid
scheme. |
Another legal victory for Slatkin trustee
Todd Neilson: The Los Angeles Times (original (registration required) or via Google) reported today that lawfirm Bryan Cave LLP, which
represented Slatkin during his 2000 appearance before the Securities and
Exchange Commission, will pay $650,000 to settle a lawsuit launched by Neilson
that argued the firm should have realized that Slatkin was running a Ponzi
scheme:
Slatkin’s attorney, Gerald Boltz, a former Securities and Exchange
Commission administrator, should have discovered the pyramid scheme in early
2000, shortly after he was hired, Neilson said. But Slatkin’s scheme wasn’t
spotted until it began to come apart shortly before he filed for Chapter 11
bankruptcy protection in May 2001. "Bryan Cave did not recognize possible signs
that Slatkin was running a Ponzi scheme, or at the very least defrauding
hundreds of investors," Neilson said in a court filing.
Boltz and other Bryan Cave officials declined to comment.
Under the terms of a tentative settlement filed last week, the law firm does
not admit to wrongdoing. But it will pay $650,000 to Slatkin’s trust to be
distributed to creditors, said R. Alexander Pilmer, Neilson’s attorney.
|
 |
| slatkinfraud.com |
| "The domino effect of misery is too extensive to be measured by
just the $240 million lost ... We want justice": Gregory Abbott speaks
out
2003-09-08 |
Full text of
Slatkin Creditor Committee Co-Chair Greg Abbott’s appearance before Slatkin’s
sentencing hearing on September 2, 2003 |
In his plea before the court, Creditor
Committee Co-Chair Greg Abbott said that he came forward not just on his own
behalf, but for those who could not afford to be in the courtroom on the day of
Slatkin’s sentencing:
I am speaking not just for myself and my family, but for hundreds of
smaller investors who can’t afford to come here and speak, who may have in fact
been damaged far more in relative terms than I have been, whose collective
suffering is monumental. I have commiserated with many of these victims, and
they want and deserve justice. Hundreds of lives have been permanently
disfigured – not just the victims but their family members and those connected
to or dependent on them. The domino effect of misery is too extensive to be
measured by just the $240 million lost by them. Despite the
fact that Slatkin will finally be sentenced, Abbott says there are still many
unanswered questions as to what became of the millions of dollars in ill-gotten
Ponzi gains -- and blames Slatkin’s reluctance to cooperate for allowing alleged
co-conspirator and longtime Scientologist Tony Hitchman to flee the country
before he could be questioned about his role in the scam:
Slatkin’s stalling enabled one of his oldest buddies Tony Hitchman,
who was on his monthly payroll, who owes the Slatkin estate millions of dollars
and may have known of the Ponzi from the very beginning, to flee the country
just ahead of a subpoena. Slatkin still won’t answer questions about his
hundreds of overseas phone calls, his foreign bank accounts, or his and Ron
Rakow’s many journeys abroad. He still hasn’t come clean about the full extent
of the gold coins and silver bullion, the crated art, and the staggering amounts
of cash the FBI found when they raided his and Rakow’s homes. We strongly
suspect he has stashed away millions, which will be waiting for him when he gets
out of prison. Had Slatkin been as proactively helpful to us as he was
proactively a criminal -- in the spirit of the plea agreement -- millions in
legal fees could have been saved and distributed to victims. Instead, Slatkin
and his attorneys are floating a smokescreen of theories in order to obscure
reality, from saying that Slatkin made some of us offsetting money at EarthLink
to claiming that he was brainwashed by the Church of Scientology. With all due
respect, the only brainwashing that took place was Slatkin brainwashing his
investors and the SEC. To read the full speech, click here. |
 |
| slatkinfraud.com |
| ***EXCLUSIVE: Eyewitness court report and hearing summary by
slatkinfraud.com correspondent
2003-09-04 |
 |
As promised, slatkinfraud.com has obtained a
detailed summary of yesterday’s hearing from a regular reader
and Slatkin-watcher who prefers to remain anonymous. The report gives added
colour and context to the story - and it’s almost as good as being right there
in the courtroom:
To understand how far Reed Slatkin has come, know that even some of
the people who knew him, who invested with him, and who had him over to their
homes, did not recognize him seated at the defense table. But then, Reed hardly
looked at the Los Angeles courtroom audience of approximately 40 who filled
every available seat and even stood at the back, at least at first. Many were
the very people he had both befriended and defrauded. Perhaps it was his
significant bald spot; did he used to have a toupee? Wearing a green
windbreaker, grey t-shirt, blue pants, and white slippers, Reed’s prison garb
was not the type of clothing seen at Hope Ranch. Neither were the handcuffs,
tied to a chain around his waist, nor the leg cuffs, that he wore the entire
time of the four-hour proceeding, but they were pretty much not noticed by many
in the courtroom until he rose to speak. Read the full report
here. slatkinfraud.com would like to thank our correspondent
for the time he spent sitting through this hearing, and writing it up for our
readers. We’d also be happy to publish any other accounts of the hearing, or any
other thoughts on the sentencing of Reed Slatkin from his erstwhile investors.
Confidentiality will, as always, be protected. Email info@slatkinfraud.com to tell us your
story. |
 |
| LA Times |
| Reed Slatkin Given 14-Year Prison Term (registration required)
or via GoogleGroups
2003-09-03 |
The District
Court ruling factors in the harm the former money manager caused bilked
investors |
[ ... ] Investors who had criticized prosecutors’ recommendation
for an 11-year sentence praised the judge for coming down heavily on Slatkin,
54, who lived on a four-acre estate near Santa Barbara, accumulated an extensive
collection of art and spent lavishly on cars and airplanes. But one Slatkin
victim, former venture capitalist John Poitras, said the 14-year sentence was
too little for someone who cost his purported friends their retirement funds,
college savings and proceeds from sales of businesses.
The sentence was
"a slap on both wrists" and "an insult to the victims," said Poitras, who lost
$15 million. "The system is still broken."
A lawyer for the Church of
Scientology praised the judge, saying she "saw right through" Slatkin’s claims
about Scientologists. "The church had nothing to do with the fact that he lied,
cheated and stole," the lawyer, David Schindler, said after the hearing.
Slatkin’s fraudulent financial empire lasted 15 years, dissolving into
bankruptcy proceedings in May 2001, leaving investors with a loss prosecutors
set at $240 million. Taken into custody in April 2002, he pleaded guilty to 15
counts of fraud, conspiracy and money laundering. [ ... ] |
 |
| Santa Barbara News Press |
| Slatkin handed 14-year sentence (via GoogleGroups)
2003-09-03 |
Claim that
church to blame for massive scam rejected |
[ ... ] U.S. District Judge Margaret M. Morrow rejected defense
claims that Mr. Slatkin had kept his fraud going for 15 years because of his
strong beliefs in - and fear of - the Church of Scientology, saying that she
wasn’t convinced he acted under such duress.
"There is no evidence the
church urged the defendant to engage in this conduct," she said from the bench,
moments before handing down a sentence more than double the 6 1/2-year term
urged by Mr. Slatkin’s attorneys. It is three years longer than the sentence
recommended by Assistant U.S. Attorney Steven Olson, for what was one of the
biggest Ponzi schemes in U.S. history.
"The harm is immense," Judge
Morrow noted. "Innumerable lives have been damaged or destroyed. He even cajoled
people with fake illnesses to get them to invest," all the while living a
"lavish lifestyle" filled with Lear jets, luxury cars, a beautiful home and
expensive country-club memberships. [ ... ] |
 |
| LA Times |
| Defrauded Investors Have
Stories to Tell
2003-09-02 |
Slatkin’s
victims, who thought he was a friend, want no leniency at his sentencing
today. |
On the day of his sentencing hearing, Reed
Slatkin makes the front page of the LA Times business section:
During more than 15 years of fraud that cost his investors $240
million, Reed E. Slatkin seemed as much trusted friend as money manager. He
schmoozed clients with tips on how to landscape their estates, attended funerals
of their family members and all the while offered assurances that he would
protect their college and retirement funds. His victims have asked to tell some
of those stories today at Slatkin’s sentencing hearing in Los Angeles, hoping to
persuade U.S. District Judge Margaret M. Morrow to throw the book at the former
Santa Barbara financial advisor. Read the full story here (registration required) or a transcript of the text via
Google Groups here. |
 |
| MSN Money & Reuters |
| Ex-EarthLink Executive Is Heading to Jail
2003-09-02 |
 |
Slatkin, who had a number of celebrity and high-profile clients, had
portrayed himself as a shrewd manager whose investments were outstripping the
market, but prosecutors said he was actually running a Ponzi scheme. His
attorneys blamed much of his behavior on the influence of the Church of
Scientology, of which he was a member and from where many of his victims came.
``There is no question that the hold the Church had on Mr. Slatkin was
significant,’’ lawyer Brian Sun told the court. ``It took us a while to
de-program Mr. Slatkin.’’ But an attorney for the Church told Reuters that
Slatkin’s claims, and those of his lawyers, were all a ruse designed to draw
attention away from his crimes. ``We were pleased the judge saw through it,’’
said David Schindler, an attorney from the firm of Latham & Watkins who
represents the Church. ``It was shameful of (Slatkin). He sold the psychiatrists
a bill of goods.’’ |
 |
| Associated Press |
| Reed Slatkin gets 14 years in prison for huge investment
scam
2003-09-02 |
 |
Slatkin’s attorneys claimed he was influenced by the Church of
Scientology, from which he has been ousted. His attorneys said investors who did
receive returns donated between $25 million and $50 million to the church, an
arrangement Slatkin was afraid to end. David Schindler, an attorney for the
Church of Scientology, was present for the sentencing. He said later the
comments were outrageous. The judge noted that during most of the time
Slatkin was allegedly in fear, he lived a lavish lifestyle. |
 |
| slatkinfraud.com |
| Date confusion - Sentencing
hearing
2003-08-29 |
 |
|
Slatkinfraud.com would like to apologize for the recent confusion surrounding
the date on which Reed Slatkin will appear before Judge Margaret Morrow for
sentencing.
In the last week, several sources have contacted us to let
us know that the hearing will take place on Tuesday, September 2 at 9:30 A.M.
However, the docket report for Judge Morrow’s court shows the hearing
scheduled for Wednesday, September 3, 2003:
8/18/03 28 MINUTES OF IN CHAMBERS HEARING held before Judge
Margaret M. Morrow as to Reed E Slatkin: Continuing sentence hearing for
9:30 9/3/03 for Reed E Slatkin. C/R: None. (step) [Entry date
08/25/03]
It is very possible that the later date is simply a typographical error on
the court webpage, and we will do our best to clarify this question as quickly
as possible, so that those who are interested in dropping by the courtroom to
watch justice take place will be able to do so.
While attempting to determine the exact date of next week’s hearing, we also
noticed that several of Slatkin’s victims have filed letters with the court in
advance of sentencing, including his fellow Scientologists, Charles Borom and
Charles Ohl:
8/27/03 29 LETTER re defendant sentence filed as to Reed E Slatkin
by Terry Johnston (ca) [Entry date 08/28/03]
8/27/03 30 LETTER Re: Sentencing filed as to Reed E Slatkin by
Charles Borom (ca) [Entry date 08/28/03]
8/27/03 31 LETTER Re: Sentencing filed as to Reed E Slatkin by
Charles N. Ohl (ca) [Entry date 08/28/03]
Given the rumour that Slatkin will attempt to dodge a heavy sentence by
blaming Scientology "brainwashing", we are, of course, most curious as to how
his (former?) fellow Scientologists will react to this particular legal dodge.
|
 |
| slatkinfraud.com |
| News from the Slatkin Front
- Sentencing Countdown: Six Days to Go!
2003-08-28 |
 |
| To tide over Slatkin watchers until next
week’s sentencing hearing, currently scheduled for September 3, 2003, here are
some new tidbits courtesy of the Slatkin rumour mill.
A correspondent to info@slatkinfraud.com (anonymous,
naturally) tells us that Reed may, indeed, lay the blame on Scientology
brainwashing at next week’s sentencing hearing, and plead for mercy on the
grounds of mental illness.
If this sounds too fantastic for Slatkin-watchers, we offer this entry in the
docket report from the court itself:
8/11/03 23 ORDER filed by Judge Margaret M. Morrow as to Reed
E Slatkin: granting ex parte application for order permitting filing under
seal of (1) Sentencing Memorandum and Exhibits of Defendant Reed e. Slatkin;
and (2) Report of Shelia Balkan, PH.D. and Exhibits [22-1] (cc: all counsel)
(roz) [Entry date 08/12/03]
Note the report from Sheila Balkan, a Santa Monica criminologist and private
investigator who has authored several widely-cited papers on criminal behaviour
who, in 2001, was touted to be the "real-life" model for a planned NBC crime drama about a
female criminologist. Will her next role be as apologist for Reed Slatkin?
Since the filing is under seal, we’ll just have to wait until September 3 to
find out, but our correspondent suggests that Slatkin’s attorneys are pushing
for a 3-5 year sentence - far less than the double digits initially sought by
the state. Even if he did throw himself on the mercy of the court with a "Scientology made
me do it" defence, it’s likely that a such a light sentence would satisfy
the hundreds of bilked investors who want to see Slatkin due hard time for his
crimes.
But just how "hard" is the year and a half of jail time that Slatkin has
served so far? Our sources say that far from pining for the fresh air and
unrestricted privileges of his erstwhile Hope Ranch estate, Slatkin is actually
enjoying his time in prison, morphing into a real-life Andy Dufresne. We
hear the inveterate schmoozer is not only winning friends and influencing people
within the convict population, but is actually giving them investment advice -
advice the prison guards are heeding as well!
In other news, we’re told that Mary Jo Slatkin, the embattled soon-to-be-ex
Ponzi spouse, has resurfaced, and is seeking comfort - both emotional and
financial - from her former friends, many of whom were victimized by her
husband’s scheme.
According to witnesses who have heard her tale of woe, Mary Jo claims that
the day her husband turned himself into authorities, he blithely informed her
that he was "just going to LA for the day." Of course, he’s been in jail ever
since. But instead of tying yellow ribbons round an old oak tree, the embattled
Mary Jo, who is reportedly facing six figure liens courtesy of the IRS, is
headed off to divorce court to rid herself of her troublesome spouse.
Our source also reveals that up to this point, the Slatkin children have
sided with their father in the familial dispute, who has assured them that the
whole matter is just a big misunderstanding that he will explain later. It’s not
clear whether the Mess’rs Slatkin, who were both submitted to
Scientology auditing performed by Slatkin co-conspirator Dan Jacobs, are
equally serene with their father’s reported about face on his once beloved
faith. |
 |
| slatkinfraud.com |
| New Slatkin sentencing date
- September 2, 2003 @ 9:30 a.m.
2003-08-22 |
 |
| According to our sources (thanks, everyone
!),
Slatkin’s sentencing hearing is currently scheduled for Tuesday, September 2,
2003, in front of Judge Margaret Morrow. We’ll keep the site updated with the
latest information. We would also love to have eye-witness comments on the
procedure, so if any slatkinfraud.com readers out there are planning to attend
the hearing, please drop us a line to give us your impressions. We can be
reached at info@slatkinfraud.com,
and, as always, your privacy will be protected.
|
|
|
|
Dès que l'affaire en
question a été connue du public (et non pas quinze jours avant, lorsqu'elle fut
probablement connue des scientologues eux-mêmes), la scientologie a fait disparaître
toute mention du nom de Slatkin sur ses sites.
Original anglais du Los Angeles Times:
http://www.latimes.com
Monday, May 14, 2001
A la
pêche aux solutions dans le puzzle Slatkin
By LIZ PULLIAM WESTON, Times Staff Writer
Résumé de l'article)
L'investisseur Reed E. Slatkin a fêté son anniversaire en
compagnie de stars comme Kevin Costner et Arnold Schwarzenegger en 1999, ainsi
qu'avec quelques 150 invités.
C'était incroyable, explique Doug Neuman, co-investisseur avec Slatkin. Les
stars ne connaissaient pas Slatkin, mais la vidéo qui fut projetée montrait les
liens tissés par Slatkin pour ses investissements.
Hélas, la joie est de courte durée. Les Hollywoodiens, entrepreneurs Internet
et autres confiants qui ont passé des centaines de millions de dollars à Slatkin
essaient désormais de savoir où a passé leur argent. La Commission des Sécuriés
et Echanges enquête pour escroquerie aux placements. Slatkin doit aussi faire
face à des poursuites lancées par des investisseurs et a déposé sa demande de
faillite voici quinze jours. Le FBI a fait une saisie vendredi, mais n'a pu pour
l'instant découvrir qu'une fraction de l'argent que contrôlait Slatkin. Les
plaintes des investisseurs démontrent qu'il pourrait y avoir plus de 4 milliards
de F dans l'affaire (600 millions de dollars).
Les enquêteurs pensent qu'il pourrait s'agir d'un des plus importants
"schèmes Ponzi" jamais rencontrés (=repaiement d'intérêts ou de dividendes
grâce à l'argent des nouveaux investisseurs).
Slatkin
ne nous a pas rappelé suite aux demandes d'éclaircissement. Ses amis de longue
date espèrent encore que Slatkin, bon père de famille, activiste civique, et
chef spirituel, peut n'avoir fait aucun mal.
Neuman dit "Ce n'est pas le Reed que je connais"...
Ces amis rappellent qu'il n'a pas commencé comme gourou en investissements,
mais que sa première passion fut la scientologie. Son intérêt daterait du décès
de son père alors qu'il avait 14 ans. Il a passé par sciento- logie St Hill en
Angleterre.
Il a obtenu un diplôme avec félicitations
de l'université du Michigan en 1974, étudié les langues asiatiques à Berkeley,
s'est engagé comme membre du staff du centre des célébrités et est devenu
ministre de l'église.
Les semaines de travail qui n'en finissaient plus et le
non-salaire eurent raison de sa décision; en 1983, il commença à apprendre les
lois du marché par leçons d'un autre scientologue. Il emménagea dans une maison
de quelques pièces avec sa famille - il a deux garçons, et se servit du garage
transformé comme bureau pour ses investissements. En 85, il travaillait pour un
petit groupe de scientologues "amplifiant leurs efforts pour l'église"
dit-il.
On disait aux investisseurs que leurs sous étaient redirigés vers d'autres
investisseurs achetant des actions. Comme les relevés gonflaient régulièrement,
ces investisseurs expliquent qu'ils donnèrent de plus en plus de fonds à
Slatkin, et encouragèrent leur famille et relations à faire de même.
"Il ne promettait rien qui ait l'air impossible," - juste assez pour qu'on
n'ait pas envie de retirer l'argent, explique Michael Stoller, avocat pour un
investisseur.
Il achète une seconde maison à Santa Barbara
En 93, la famille déménage dans une propriété de la zône du Hope Ranch à
Santa Barbara - on y trouve un lac des cygnes, un golf, des chènes. Mais il
conserva sa maison de Goleta comme bureau.
Les investissements de Slatkin ne disparurent pas tous. Il dit s'être essayé
à plusieurs reprises aux investissements à haut risque. Il acheta par exemple 20% des actions d'une affaire "Havenwood Ventures Inc", qui devait bâtir un parc
à thêmes (lequel ne vit jamais le jour).
Mais ces investissements à risques marchèrent mieux en 1994, quand il fut
contacté par un scientologue, Kevin O'Donnell, qui lui fit investir auprès d'un
autre jeune scientologue nommé Sky Dayton, 22 ans, qui désirait monter une
affaire autour d'internet. Slatkin investit 75'000 dollars. Or, Earthlink Network
allait devenir le troisième fournisseur d'accès national.
Les actions de Slatkin valaient 122 millions de dollars en février 2000. Et
lui fournissaient un accès à d'autres grands investisseurs. Ce qui lui donna une
image stellaire d'une grand investisseur doublé d'un dirigeant de société qui
réussissait.
Quatre dirigeants de Earthlink lui donnèrent de l'argent à investir, dont
Dayton, Charles Garry Betty, ainsi que divers bénévoles s'occupant d'organismes
sociaux par ailleurs.
Slatkin atteignit alors Hollywood - grâce à ses
liens scientologues, ainsi que l'investissement O'Donnell en 99, une société de
production cinématographioque dirigée par Armyan Bernstein.
La clientèle de Slatkin toucha des cabinets d'avocats, de comptablité, des
fonds de pension et de tas d'investisseurs privés. Certains y mirent moins de
100 000 dollars, d'autres dépassant 10 millions.
Alice Wintz, paralysée qui a investi environ 1,5 million reçus des assurances
après accident de voiture et les frais d'école de ses enfants, craint que
l'argent ne revienne pas. "C'est tout ce que j'avais, explique Wintz, qui se
déplace en voiturette. Elle était présente lors de la réunion des créditeurs qui
s'est tenue la semaine passée.
En 99, Slatkin maniait au moins 230 millions pour plus de 500 investisseurs.
Il avait expliqué qu'il ferait "la faveur" de s'occuper de leur argent à ses
clients - mais demandait habituellement 10 % pour prix de cette faveur.
Les comptes de réassurances étaient liquidés
De janvier à décembre 2000, Slatkin et ses avocats ont garanti à
l'enquèteur de la SEC que les comptes étaient liquidés et qu'ils rendaient
l'argent aux investisseurs. Le 27 décembre 2000, il indiquait en avoir fini et
répétait la même chose dans une lettre du 29 mars à la SEC. Ce n'est pas ce que
les centaines d'investisseurs de Slatkin apprirent. Des centaines de millions de
dollars sont encore dues.
Lors d'entretiens et de poursuites devant les tribunaux, les
investisseurs indiquèrent aussi qu'ils commencè- rent à avoir des problèmes pour
sortir l'argent de leurs comptes au moment où les valeurs start-up
s'effon- drèrent - en mars 2000.
Slatkin reçut cependant de nouvelles sommes - 64 millions de $ de nouveaux
dépôts entre septembre 99 et septembre 2000, et il chercha activement de
nouveaux clients jusqu'en février de cette année. Le service des faillites US
pense que plus de 600 millions pourraient être disparus.
Premières plaintes le 12 avril
Le SEC explique que Slatkin
avait vraisemblablement monté un "schème Ponzi", opération où les nouveaux
investisseurs paient les intérêts et le principal des anciens.
Les enquèteurs ne savent pas pour l'instant ce que Slatkin avait investi ni
où est passé l'argent.
Le 12 avril, les investisseurs ont déposé une première plainte sur les trois,
l'accusant d'escroquerie pour ne pas leur avoir rendu quelques 35 millions de
dollars.
Slatkin a démissionné du conseil de Earthlink le 26 avril et demandé la
protection de la loi sur les faillites, estimant les dettes à 100 millions de
dollars et les disponibilités à 50 millions.
Vendredi, les agents du FBI et de l'IRS faisaient une descente aux bureaux de
Slatkin à Goleta. Le SEC obtenait un ordre de gel des comptes par le tribunal,
sur la base d'investissements frauduleux effectués depuis 1985.
Le SEC a trouvé moins de 30 millions de $ sur les comptes de Slatkin. Les
comptes en Suisse que Slatkin prétendait contenir 585 millions de plus
n'existent pas, semblerait-il.
On ignore combien de cet argent confié pourra être récupéré, explique Richard
Wynne avocat de Slatkin.
Par ailleurs de nombreux autres "scientologues avancés"
ont été impliqués dans des escroqueries d'importance, la secte n'étant pas
blanche. Voir par exemple:
Revenons sur la dernière escroquerie d'un très haut scientologue -
Reed Slatkin - qui se trouve désormais face à des centaines de plaignants et
des **milliards de F** de dettes. Slatkin était rappelons-le l'un des
fondateurs d'Earthlink, FAI américain de première grandeur.
On peut se demander ce que l'on va découvrir en matière de
dévoiement possible des circuits financiers par la scientologie, ou de
blanchiment d'argent via des sociétés ayant un ou plusieurs dirigeants
scientologues (dont la célèbrissime "Clearstream" suisso-luxembourgeoise).
Rappelons que Clearstream, 2e société mondiale de "stockage" de titres
financiers, est mise en cause dans des affaires de blanchiment financier et
de comptes secrets, et qu'on aurait constaté qu'elle possède au moins un
dirigeant scientologue
Rappelons que la banque au Luxembourg avait refusé d'expliquer la provenance des sommes
importantes transitant sur le compte de la scientologie à la justice française. Qu'ont-ils à cacher
?
Rappelons aussi l'affaire suisse encore
récemment devant les tribunaux:
Un ex-scientologue a escroqué 300
investisseurs de quelques 90 millions de FF. Il ne veut cependant pas
accepter la prison.
Zurich, Switzerland March 3,
2001 Tages-Anzeiger http://tages-anzeiger.ch par Hugo Stamm
Fin
des années 80 début 90, des scientologues ont provoqué des pertes financières
partiellement fraudu- leuses pour un montant de 400 millions. L'un d'eux,
[Kaspar Rhyner], ancien juge et cadre bancaire, a passé vendredi en Cour
Supérieure. Il a écopé de 2 ans et neuf mois de prison ferme.
Son
co-défendant de 40 ans, qui était responsable de la programmation
dans l'affaire et écopa quant à lui de six mois en premier lieu, a
clairement expliqué d'emblée: "Si nous n'avions pas été scientologues, nous
ne serions certainement pas ici aujourd'hui, je peux vous le garantir." Cela
en tête, le co-défenseur invisible rôda dans le tribunal : c'est la
Scientologie, qui se retrouve au coeur des discussions ici.
Raison
primordiale : l'argent cher joue un rôle pimordial dans l'organisation. Les
deux accusés avaient d'énormes dettes afin de payer "léglise": 1,4 million et
1,8 million de cours et "services". De plus, l'avocat avait acheté pour des
millions de FF des peintures sans valeur représentant le fondateur de la
secte, Hubbard, et avait amassé des dettes de 14 millions de
FF.
Une banque Rothschild" fondée...
Une fois que le
principal défenseur tomba sur cette source financière paresseuse et
intarissable, il n'y eut plus rien pour l'arrèter. Il partit en quête
d'investisseurs pour le compte d'un homme d'affaires munichois. Les annonces
qu'ils passèrent parlaient de "L'association fédérale des
banques américaines" et promettait des intérêts de 9 à 10 %. Mais on ne
trouvait là-dessous que 2 bureaux portant le nom rassurant de "Banque
Rothschild". De 91 à 94, l'inté- ressé prit l'argent, surtout en liquide, et
l'emmena à Münich. Il empocha ainsi 2,5 millions de commissions de
l'allemand. Une fois le pot-aux-roses découvert, le munichois disparut dans
la nature et ne reparut plus jamais.
Le co-défenseur quadragénaire a
travaillé comme technicien informatique pour le collègue scientologue. Le
tribunal de district a estimé qu'il s'agissait d'une complicité et d'une
escroquerie commerciale et a exigé que les scientologues compensent ensemble
pour les torts chiffrés en millions. Ils ont fait appel, trouvant la sentence
trop élevée. Le défenseur principal a demandé une réduction de sa peine à six
mois avec sursis, son co-défenseur demandant la relaxe.
Il a expliqué
avoir fait entière confiance à son partenaire en affaires de Münich. Il dit
n'avoir jamais soupçonné que son partenaire ait pu escroquer les fonds
jusqu'à peu de temps avant l'effondrement.Son avocat a dit que qu'il y avait
un lien avec tous les cours que son client avait pris en scientologie : il
explique que son client a fortement été influencé mentalement et qu'il a
appris à refouler ses doutes. De plus, on dit que ces cours ont profondément
modifié sa structure de pensée.
Son co-défendant et l'avocat de ce
dernier ont enfoncé un peu plus le clou. Ils ont parlé d'incapacité à
différencier, de systèmes totalitaires, deprocédures inquisitoriales et de
lavage de cerveau. Les juges ont aussi poséquestion après question sur la
scientologie. Mais n'ont pour l'instantécarté aucune part de
l'accusation.
http://news.newspress.com/toplocal/slatkins0621.htm
Les biens
de Slatkin sont visés
Investissements: Le Hope Ranch pourrait servir à payer une nuée de
créanciers.
6/21/01
Par MARK VAN DE KAMP Du NEWS-PRESS
Le
spécialiste en investissement Reed E. Slatkin, qui a été mis en faillite,
pourrait vendre son bien immobilier le Hope Ranch et d'autres propriétés, ainsi
que plus d'un million de dollars en oeuvre d'art et en pièces de collection,
même son titre de membre du La Cumbre Country Club, si l'équipe du groupe de
travail sur les faillites continue à fouiller et à saisir ses biens.
L'équipe en question, menée par R. Todd Neilson de Los Angeles, un fondé
de pouvoir nommé par le tribunal, cherche activement à se faire une image exacte
des affaires financières avant le 23 juillet et à établir la liste des biens,
qui pourront être vendus pour rembourser les créanciers.
Les régulateurs fédéraux disent que Mr Slatkin a escroqué des centaines
de personnes pour une valeur d'au moins 230 millions de dollars à l'aide de son
affaire d'investissements non déclarée. Les avocats ont répertorié cette semaine
les créanciers qui sont au nombre de 850, alors qu'on pensait auparavant qu'ils
n'étaient que 500, et ils maintiennent que l'ensemble de la dette pourrait
dépasser 600 millions de dollars.
Environ 75 des créanciers habitent le comté de Santa Barbara, d'après les
informations déposées devant les tribunaux.
Prélude à une vente possible, le fondé de pouvoir a inspecté le Ranch
Hope de Slatkin mercredi, afin d'évaluer l'état des bâtiments. Cette propriété
qui se trouve au 4480 et 4484 Via Esperanza vaut 3,4 millions de dollars, mais
ces propriétés se vendent facilement à un prix supérieur à ce qu'elles ont été
estimées.
Une propriété de Mr Slatkin, dans Santa Ynez Valley d'environ 40
hectares, a été également inspectée.
L'équipe du fondé de pouvoir enquête
également sur les procédures pour vendre la carte de membre de La Cumbre Country
Club de Hope Ranch de Mr Slatkin, qui donne accès à un golf de 18 trous. Un
officiel du club dit que ces cartes valent facilement 100 000
dollars.
L'équipe du fondé de pouvoir a appris que Mr Slatkin possédait
de nombreuses pièces de collection, y compris des toiles de Albert Bierstadt et
Thomas Hart Benton. Dans une lettre aux avocats de Mr Slatkin, le fondé de
pouvoir demande que ces pièces et d'autres, soient immédiatement placées sous
séquestre.
Mr slatkin a de lui-même déclaré faillite d'après le chapitre 11 en date
du 1er mai, en expliquant que ses dettes dépassaient 100 millions de dollars.
Les créanciers, avocats et fondé de pouvoir ont exprimé leur mécontentement
quant au fait qu'il n'ait pas obéi aux exigences du tribunal, de fournir la
liste complète de ses biens, de ses affaires financières lors des sept semaines
qui ont suivi.
L'équipe du fondé de pouvoir essaie activement d'obtenir ces
renseignements. De plus, c'est près de 320 cartons de documents concernant Mr
Slatkin qui ont été fournis par les agents fédéraux et par l'agence de
comptabilité.
Le chapitre 11 permet à un débiteur de rester en possession de ses biens
temporairement, le temps qu'il essaie de s'organiser.
Cette semaine, Mr.
Neilson a identifié une "liste importante de titres, d'hypothèques et autres
notes de frais" qui ne se trouvaient pas dans les comptes et a demandé qu'elle
lui soit transmise. Il a également ordonné à 39 sociétés de courtage et à des
banques de geler tous les comptes de Slatkin et de lui faire passer tous les
biens en liquide, comme en donnait l'ordre le tribunal.
Des centaines de créanciers sont invités le 30 juillet à Santa Barbara,
peut-être à l'hotel ou dans le bureau du fondé de pouvoir, pour discuter du
procés. Nombre des créanciers, dont certains ont investi plus d'un million de
dollars, se demandent combien ils pourront récupérer, leurs avocats les ont
avertis qu'il ne pouvait s'agir que de quelques pennies par dollar investi.
Mr Slatkin réside à Hope Ranch depuis huit ans et il est co-fondateur de
EarthLink, un important fournisseur d'accès Internet. Il a abandonné son poste
au conseil d'administration en avril.
Selon les documents du tribunal,
les avocats et les régulateurs, Mr Slatkin, qui n'est pas déclaré en tant que
conseiller financier, avait dit qu'il faisait fonctionner un club
d'investissement pour ses amis et ses connaissances et que ce n'était pas
commercial. Il a commencé ses activités en 1985, en recueillant de l'argent
auprès d'amis, de partenaires en affaires et de membres de l'Eglise de
Scientologie dont il fait partie.
Les investisseurs ont dit qu'il leur avait promis de gros gains --
parfois 60% l'an -- mais les enquêteurs fédéraux le soupçonnent d'avoir payé
certains avec l'argent des investisseurs suivants, un type d'escroquerie connu
sous le nom de Ponzi scheme.
Times staff writers Claudia Eller and Karen Kaplan contributed to this
story.
http://www.thestandard.com |
-
From: http://www.thestandard.com/article/0,1902,436,00.html
EarthLink
Connects By Michelle V. Rafter May 28 1998 12:00 AM PDT
The
Southern California Internet Service Provider has defied conventional wisdom
just by surviving. Now Dayton and Betty are betting the company on a $180
million deal with
Sprint.
-----------------------------------------
Driving
down a steep mountain road after a weekend on the slopes of Big Bear in Southern
California, EarthLink Network (ELNK) founder Sky Dayton and his promising COO
candidate, Charles "Garry" Betty, had an unexpected chance to see how well they
worked together. A storm the previous night had covered the road with a slick
layer of ice and snow, and the way ahead was obscured by a swirling blanket
of fog.
Although an avid snowboarder, Dayton hadn't brought chains for his
BMW M5. He remembers thinking he wouldn't make it off the mountain. But Betty
took charge from the passenger seat and coached Dayton through every mile of
icy, hairpin curves.
The 1996 ski trip was the then 24-year-old Dayton's
idea of a final interview for Betty, a Georgia native 15 years his senior.
Betty got the job at the fledgling ISP and rose to CEO six months
later.
Dayton and Betty may be nearly a generation apart, but their close
working relationship lies at the heart of the company's success. Dayton, an
ambitious GenXer who never went to college, started EarthLink on little more
than a dream, but it was the industry-wise Betty who took Dayton's vision and
ran with it.
At a time when most consumer ISPs still counted customers in
the thousands and analysts regularly issued dire warnings of
telephone companies and cable operators engulfing the industry, the two men
transformed EarthLink from a small Southern California outfit to a national
powerhouse. In three years, EarthLink has amassed more than 500,000 subscribers,
seen revenue more than triple to $79.2 million in 1997 and watched its stock
price soar. Since the company's January 1997 initial public offering, EarthLink
stock rose from $13 to a high of $77 before slipping lately to $58.375,
giving it a market capitalization of $610.9 million.
The secret of
Dayton's and Betty's success has been equal parts intuition, luck, timing and
moxie. Colleagues and analysts credit Dayton with a keen ability to act early
on trends: He leased bandwidth rather than build his own network infrastructure
and dropped prices to $19.95 a month for unlimited access before other ISPs
saw the wisdom of flat rates.
Time and again, Dayton and Betty have also
found ways to raise cash from public markets and private investors just when
they needed it most. This week, EarthLink expects to close a deal with Sprint
that analysts calculate is worth about $180 million in cash, credit lines and
new subscribers. EarthLink is looking to raise another $174 million in a
secondary stock offering set to take place later this month. Fueled by the
new funding, analysts believe EarthLink could become the nation's No. 2 consumer
gateway to the Net by 1999.
But questions remain about the future of
the EarthLink Sprint (dossier) deal. EarthLink has yet to make a nickel, and
won't for at least another two years because of write-offs associated with
the deal, according to analysts who follow the stock. Likewise, Sprint could
prove more of a hindrance than a help to EarthLink. A latecomer to the consumer
dial up business, Sprint has seen its Internet Passport service flounder
while the company invested in other areas. And executives at both companies
won't rule out the possibility that Sprint could buy EarthLink after a
three-year hands-off period spelled out in their deal.
If Dayton has his
way, though, EarthLink will still be independent in the future - and he'll still
be running it. "Somebody has to be out way ahead saying we have a long way to
go," he says. "It doesn't keep me up at night, but I do worry. Are we talking
to customers ? Is our present technology palatable ? Our bread and butter for
many years to come will still be getting people connected."
The Internet
was relatively unexplored territory when Dayton first caught wind of it in 1993.
As a teenager, he had tinkered with computers - his grandfather was an IBM
fellow - and had worshiped motorcycles and fast cars. He hung out with a crowd
in Los Angeles' Los Feliz neighborhood that vowed to be millionaires by the
time they were in their 20s.
A practicing Scientologist, Dayton graduated
at age 16 from the Delphian Academy, a Scientology-affiliated boarding school
in Sheridan, Ore. But ambition moved him to choose entrepreneurship over
college. His first venture was a money-losing coffeehouse named Cafe Mocha,
located on trendy Melrose Avenue in L.A. Dayton's next business was a graphic
design shop, started with long-time friend Adam Walker.
When another
friend introduced him to the Internet, Dayton says he spent more than 60
frustrating hours attempting to establish a TCP/IP connection. The experience
sparked an idea for a business: An Internet access provider that would make it
as easy as possible for novices like himself to log on.
To fund the
venture, Dayton talked to anyone who would listen, eventually hooking up with
two Sciento- logists who would become his first angel investors. He raised
$100,000 by selling a 40 percent stake to Kevin O'Donnell - the father of a
school friend and founder of Government Technology Services Inc., a
Chantilly, Va., computer reseller - and Reed Slatkin, a Santa Barbara,
Calif., stock trader, financial manager and long-time friend of Walker's
family.
Equally important, O'Donnell and Slatkin acted as Dayton's
management and financial advisors, filling gaps in his limited experience.
Both O'Donnell and Slatkin remain on the board, and although EarthLink's
subsequent private and public offerings have diluted their stakes, they still
hold 7.9 percent and 8.8 percent of the company's shares, respectively. The only
shareholders whose stakes are higher are Dayton, who owns approximately 10
percent of EarthLink shares, and billionaire financier George Soros, who
has acquired approximately 10 percent through several private
placements.
In 1994 EarthLink introduced its first sign-on software kit,
an all-in-one bundle with TCP/IP, e-mail, a Web browser and other Internet
software that was among the first of its kind. To help run the business, Dayton
hired friends and drew on management courses he'd taken at L.A.'s Hubbard
College of Administration International, another Scientology-affiliated
school.
Dayton acknowledges the role his Scientology training played in
his career: He says it helped him learn new subjects quickly, think for
himself, manage people and structure a growing company.
"I've found that
the approaches I started with were totally common sense," Dayton says. "Every
good manager applies them anyway."
In EarthLink's early days, some
employees objected to the company's Scientology techniques and the company drew
suspicion after the Church's controversial role in cases involving free
speech on the Internet.
But EarthLink's Scientology influence waned as
the company grew, according to people who worked there at the time. The change
became most apparent, they say, after Dayton hired Betty, a veteran corporate
exec who had run networking-software company Digital Communications
Associates and had held management posts at modem-maker Hayes
Microcomputer.
Acquaintances such as Linwood A. "Chip" Lacy, an EarthLink
director and investor since 1995, credit Dayton with a maturity beyond his
years, comparing him to computer wunderkind Michael Dell, who started Dell
Computer while an undergraduate. The best indicator of Dayton's maturity was
his decision to hire Betty when the company was still small, says Lacy, former
co-chairman of computer distributor Ingram Micro.
"We've all dealt
with founders who can't make that transition, but he wanted this company to
fulfill its destiny," Lacy says.
Dayton's admirers also credit him with
the prescient decision not to invest in building his own Internet network. While
other ISPs were spending precious capital erecting modem banks and high-speed
fiber-optic lines, Dayton figured EarthLink was better off buying access from
IP backbone wholesalers and spending its money snagging customers.
In
1995 EarthLink signed a wholesale bandwidth agreement with UUNET, instantly
transforming itself into a national provider and giving itself an endless
supply of bandwidth. EarthLink immedately cut its monthly fee to $19.95 for
unlimited access, the first ISP in the country to offer a cheap,
all-you-can-eat dial-up plan. Later EarthLink signed a similar wholesale access
contract with PSINet, bringing the number of dial-in numbers it offers to
1,100. As part of the Sprint deal, Sprint will become EarthLink's
third access provider, adding 200 access numbers.
By 1997 most
consumer ISPs had gotten out of the once-novel Internet backbone business and
leased capacity from major providers such as UUNET (dossier) or MCI. With
high-speed cable modem and digital subscriber line (DSL) technologies around the
corner, it now makes more sense than ever for consumer ISPs to be "network
agnostic," says Forrester Research analyst Kate Delhagen.
In many ways,
Dayton and Betty are opposites. Tall and lank, with close-cropped brown hair,
Dayton, now 26, is guarded in conversation and is well known as the company's
resident worrier. "I worry about everything," he says. Betty, 41, is more jovial
and open.
For the past two years, Dayton has played Mr. Outside to
Betty's Mr. Inside. Dayton represents EarthLink on the Internet
conference circuit while Betty handles the company's day-to-day operations.
One week in April found Betty in his office while Dayton flew to Washington,
D.C., to lead the president and first lady through the EarthLink sponsored
Webcast of the White House's annual Easter Egg Roll.
"I'm the original
user of our service," he says. "I go home at night and use it. I dial in via
modem. I use ISDN. I worry about all of the long-term stuff, the high-speed
access and R&D stuff."
These days Dayton, whose stake in EarthLink is
worth about $100 million, is enjoying the fruits of his labors. He bought
himself a silver 1997 Porsche Twin Turbo last fall and recently gave his mom
a Toyota RAV4. In February Dayton and his wife, Arwen, a budding screenwriter
and novelist, paid $1.9 million for a 6,400-square-foot, 1920s-era mansion in
Pasadena, Calif.
But financial success hasn't left much time for hanging
out with his old buddies. "A lot of the guys he used to spend time
with wonder what happened to him," says Walker, Dayton's one-time business
partner. "He's joined the big-business gang. That's one of the sacrifices
anyone has to make."
When Betty joined EarthLink in 1996, the company had
30,000 subscribers and was growing at a rate of 15 percent to 20 percent
a week. Despite Dayton's best efforts, the frantic pace made for virtually
nonexistent financial controls, Betty says.
"They didn't know how much
cash they had," he says. "They didn't know how much they needed, how much they
owed."
Over the following six months, Betty installed the kinds of
accounting and financial systems he'd used to manage larger, public companies
like Hayes Microcomputer. The corporate makeover helped EarthLink tap investors
for the capital it desperately needed to continue growing.
Betty
logged 80 to 100 hours a week and claims he was hooked on the company's pace
from the moment he stepped into the company's first office. "I go in to meet
Sky, and there's 200 people in this little bitty building, and the electricity
is just incredible," Betty remembers. "There's nothing like being in the
excitement of a start-up."
Before Betty's arrival, EarthLink had raised
$4.4 million from existing and new investors to promote its national status
after the UUNET deal. But the company burned through the money in a
five-month marketing blitz.
In subsequent private placements, EarthLink
raised $22.7 million, including investments from Soros, before its $26 million
public offering in January 1997. In September the company raised another
$15.4 million in a private placement, with $5 million coming from Soros'
investment arm, Soros Fund Management.
To continue its expansion,
however, it needed more funding. Betty and Dayton spent the first half of 1997
talking to the Baby Bells about marketing partnerships but came away empty
handed. Then, in September 1997, EarthLink director Sidney "Sam" Azeez, asked
his friend Carl Peterson, president and general manager of the Kansas City
Chiefs, to pass the word to Sprint Chairman William Esrey, another Peterson
buddy, that EarthLink was looking to do a deal.
Esrey liked the idea and
set the wheels in motion for a meeting between top EarthLink and Sprint execs,
which took place in Sprint's Kansas City, Mo., headquarters on Halloween.
Within a month, Esrey and top Sprint Internet managers were in Dayton's
office finalizing negotiations, and the deal was announced Feb. 11 of this
year.
"They had the scale we were looking for and the strategy and
direction right in sync with where Sprint wanted to go," says David Owen,
Sprint's Internet marketing director. " #91;Sprint] customers will be very happy
because they'll get a better product than what we provided and equal to one
we thought it would take us 12 to 18 months to get to."
Sprint will pay
$4.2 million for 10 percent of EarthLink stock, extend it a three-year,
low-interest $100-million credit line and become EarthLink's third access
provider. Sprint will also hand off to EarthLink its 130,000 Sprint Internet
Passport customers. Sprint promises to deliver another 750,000 customers over
the next five years through a joint marketing program.
In exchange,
Sprint also picks up 4.2 million restricted, nonvoting shares (in addition to
EarthLink common shares), giving it an aggregate 30 percent stake in the ISP,
as well as two seats on EarthLink's board, to be filled by Esrey and Patti
Manuel, head of the $14.8 billion company's consumer long-distance
division.
Once the deal closes, Sprint's 2,000-person telemarketing staff
will pitch "EarthLink-Sprint" Internet access to long distance customers and
prospects. Beginning in the fourth quarter, EarthLink-Sprint Internet access
will be featured in Sprint TV commercials, possibly including those starring
celebrity pitchwoman Candice Bergen.
Analysts expect additional
subscriber revenue from the deal to kick EarthLink's operations into the black
by year-end. But because EarthLink will write off an undisclosed amount of
goodwill associated with assets exchanged in the pact, the company will
continue to show a net loss for another two years, analysts and company
officials predict. In the quarter ended March 31, EarthLink lost $6.4 million
on revenue of $29.2 million, compared with a $8.4 million loss on revenue of
$15.7 million in the same period last year. In 1997 EarthLink lost $29.9
million on revenue of $79.2 million, compared with a $31.1 million loss on
revenue of $32.5 million in 1996.
To keep up with its growing customer
base, EarthLink has invested more than $23 million in a 10,000- square-foot data
center at its year-old Pasadena headquarters, which can handle the needs of
up to 3 million subscribers. EarthLink's customer-support department is in
perpetual hiring mode, and the department accounts for 600 of the company's
1,000 employees.
Ultimately, the big winner in the deal could be Sprint,
which had been a distant third behind competitors ATT (T) and MCI in
the consumer ISP business. As part of their agreement, Sprint could buy
EarthLink outright at the end of 39 months, if the companies agree on a
price. Sprint officials refuse to speculate on the likelihood of such an
acquisition.
"It's a great scenario for Sprint," says Forrester's
Delhagen. "Two or three years from now if they realize owning
Internet customers is a valuable proposition - whether they make money or
it's a feeder for their core [long-distance] business - that's a lot of
customers for Sprint."
But some question whether Sprint is up to the
challenge. "I don't think [adding 150,000 subscribers per year] is a large
threshold to meet. From what they've done in #91;the last] 18 months, they
have to be more serious," says Joe Bartlett, a Yankee Group (dossier)
analyst.
Expect to see EarthLink announce more marketing partnerships in
the coming months. EarthLink recently unveiled a marketing pact with the
Discover Card unit of Morgan Stanley Dean Witter (MWD) to offer cobranded
Internet access to 30 million Discover Card holders. In an upcoming agreement
with the Los Angeles Dodgers, EarthLink will offer "dodgerblue.com" vanity
e-mail addresses to baseball fans.
"This is so fun," Betty says of the
Sprint deal. "They've put us on the map."
Les biens et le calendrier
Slatkin...
Santa Barbara News-Press
http://news.newspress.com/topsports/033102timeline.htm
- 3/31/02
TIMELINE
*
22 janvier 49, naissance de Reed Slatkin à Detroit, Michigan
* 1963: le
père de M. Slatkin se suicide, celui-ci va vers la scientologie
* 1966:
Etudes auprès de L. Ron Hubbard à l'école de St Hill à East Grinstead, Sussex,
UK.
* 1973: Déménage sur Los Angeles avec son épouse mary jo et commence
à travailler à plein temps pour l'église de scientologie
* 1975: Ordonné
ministre de l'église, commence à entraîner d'autres scientologues.
*
1983: Après la naissance de son second fils, déménage à Goleta et commence son
apprentissange d'investisseur auprès de son ami et "coréligionnaire" Bob Duggan.
* 1984: Commence à investir et signale certaines années avec des
rendements de 100 %.
* 1987: Après avoir aidé des délinquants condamnés,
Chris Mancuso, Ron Rakow, à investir l'argent malhon- nête de l'escroquerie
"Fermes de Culture", il reçoit une note de Mancuso, qui est en prison, "Un jour
de plus au Club Fed [eral]" commence la lettre, qui poursuit: "je sais qu'on
fera de grandes choses ensemble" !
* 1988 il confesse, dans une note à
lui-même, avoir menti sur ce qu'il fait "au lieu de bosser sur la Bourse, j'ai
bossé pour faire des fausses déclarations de résultats."
* 1990: " Un associé en affaires, Patriick
Gallagher, s'inquiète des affaires menées par Slatkin; et ses programmes
d'ordinateur dissolvent toute implication avec lui. Il dit "je crains qu'une
inspection des affaires de Slatkin ne révèlent des caractéristiques scabreuses
impliquant des irrégularités en matière de règles voursières - et qu'après
analyse, cela puisse mener à des poursuites de la part de diverses agences
officielles".
* 1993: Il achète deux propriétés à Hope Ranch.
*
1994: Il rencontre Sky Dayton et Kevin O'Donnell, et décide d'investir 75000
dollars dans l'affaire qu'ils fondent, Earthlink. En trois ans, son
investissement vaudra 200 millions de dollars.
* 1995: Il explique aux
383 investisseurs de son club que les 133 millions ont fait 77 millions de
bénéfices et valent dontc 210 millions de dollars.
* 1997: La Commission
Actions et Obligations (SEC) entame une enquète informelle sur Slatkin.
*
1998: Il annonce posséder 50 millions de dollars dans un compte en banque, mais
il n'y en a que 3.
* 1999: Il dit à la SEC qu'il liquide son club et rend
l'argent aux investisseurs.
* January and February 2000 repeats claim to
SEC that he is in the "process of liquidating accounts," and that "I am not
accepting any new accounts or any money from existing accounts." Il répètre
en janvier et février 2000
* February 2000: Associate Chris Mancuso helps
set up a telephone line with a fake Swiss number that, "when you dial the
number the line has been conditioned to provide a truly genuine European ring
(nice touch, huh ?)"
* January 2000 to May 1, 2001: Mr. Slatkin takes in
more than $100 million from investors instead of closing accounts and
returning money as he promised the SEC.
* November 2000: Gets a $10
million unsecured personal loan from Sidney Azeez.
* December 2000:
Convinces John Poitras to invest an initial $5 million; he later adds another
$10 million to the pot.
* March 30: Mr. Slatkin produces a memo from a
Swiss financial firm, NAA, showing he has $380 million in investment account.
Mr. Steadman and his attorneys make a few phone calls and discover there is
no such firm as NAA in Switzerland.
* April 7, 2001: Sends letter to
investors saying: "We are experiencing delays in our ability to meet your
request for withdrawl of funds... Rest assured your funds are safe and the
delay has nothing to do with the current fluctuation in the market."
*
April 13, 2001: Frustrated that he hasn't had his money returned,
John Poitras files suit and Mr. Slatkin's assets are frozen.
* April
20, 2001: Texas foundation manager Stuart Steadman files suit to get his and
his foundation's money $18 million returned. From the quarterly statements
generated by Mr. Slatkin, Mr. Steadman thought the account had grown to $34
million.
* April 27, 2001: Denise Del Bianco, Mr. Slatkin associate and
wife of Ron Rakow, receives $1.9 million, court records show.
* April
30, 2001: In a meeting at the office of his Los Angeles attorney, first
informs his investors that there's a problem with the money.
* May 1,
2001: Files for bankruptcy.
* May 11, 2001: FBI and IRS raid and search
Mr. Slatkin's homes and offices.
* May 11, 2001: The SEC sues Mr.
Slatkin for violating federal securities laws.
* May 29, 2001: Mr.
Slatkin agrees to a consent decree to stop any investment activity.
*
May 30, 2001 FBI searches the New Mexico offices of Mr. Slatkin's bookkeeper
Jean Janu.
* June 1, 2001 a early attempt at a plea bargain is
stopped.
* June 24, 2001: FBI and IRS agents raid and search the home of
Slatkin associate Ron Rakow.
* July 30, 2001: The U.S. Bankruptcy
Trustee tells 800 investors that their money is mostly gone. He's assets
total perhaps $30 million on debts that exceed $250 million.
* August
8, 2001: The trustee begins to put Mr. Slatkin's homes and property up for
sale.
* December 14, 2001: The trustee says Slatkin's investment club was
a scam from the start.
* February 28, 2002: The last day for creditors
to file claims against the estate.
* March 25, 2002: More than 500
people and institutions have filed claims against the estate totaling $817
million.
* March 26, 2002: Reed Slatkin agrees to sign a guilty plea,
taking responsibility for $254 million in losses and admitting to
orchestrating one of the largest Ponzi schemes in history over a 15 year
period.
ASSETS
An accounting of Mr. Slatkin's assets listed a
value of just $30 million for the estate, including:
* Hundreds of
bottles of wine including four bottles of Mountain Rothschild valued at $300
each.
* One million shares of EarthLink stock, which has ranged in price
from $4.75 to $18.92 in the past year.
* Three country club
memberships: El Caballero Country Club, The Alisal and La Cumbre Country
Club.
* Vehicles: A 2001 Porshe Turbo, 2000 Volvo C70, 2001 Toyota Prius,
1967 Chevrolet Corvette, 1969 Pontiac Firebird, 1998 Lectr golfcart, 1994
Volvo 960, 1995 Jeep Grand Cherokee.
* Properties: Hope Ranch homes at
4480 and 4484 Via Esperanza estimated to be worth $6 million. Goleta home at
890 N. Kellogg Avenue estimated to be worth $775,000. Solvang property 3125
Riley Road worth about $400,000. Undeveloped property in Santa Ynez 1275
Roble Branco Road, Santa Ynez Valley 100 acres estimated to be worth about
$1.6 million. Newport Beach property 6 Sea Greens, Newport Beach, worth about
$1.14 million. Undeveloped parcels in Ashland, Ore., on Strawberry Lane worth
about $5.25 million. Interest in three malls in Tennessee, Florida and
Louisiana, worth about $14
million.
2001 - Los Angeles
Times
English
index
|
-
|